Our schools have been closed for the last 10 days. During that time I’ve been taking a little break from having my older son work on problems and am having him read Steven Strogatz’s Infinite Powers instead.
For our project tonight I asked him to pick out three chapters that he’s liked so far to discuss. He chose chapters 2, 3, and 10. As a quick note before diving in to his thoughts on these chapters, he studied calculus last year so I was having him read Strogatz’s book for history and context rather than as an introduction to calculus.
Here’s what he had to say about Chapter 2 which is about Archimedes:
Here’s what he had to say about Chapter 3 which is about Galileo and Kepler:
Finally, here’s what he had to say about Chapter 10 which is about Fourier:
I think he’s gotten a lot out of Strogatz’s book, and I was really excited to learn that he thought Fourier’s work was interesting. Maybe the Who is Fourier book really is the next right step for him.
Last week Steven Strogatz released two previously unpublished appendicies for his book Infinite Powers:
My older son and I did a fun project with Fermat’s idea. He’d taken calculus last year and the ideas Strogatz shared made for a really nice calculus review:
Sharing Appendix 1 to Steven Strogatz’s Infinite powers with my son
My younger son is in 8th grade and has not taken calculus. I thought some of the ideas about finding areas under simple curves would be interesting, so I tried sharing some of those ideas this morning.
We started by taking a look at the first page of Strogatz’s appendix and then talked about finding the area under for small values of
Now we moved on to the case . He had the really neat idea of thinking that this piece of the parabola might be a quarter circle. That idea made for a great little exploration:
I asked for another idea had he decided to chop the parabola up into rectangles. This isn’t an idea that came out of the blue because we have talked about some intro calculus ideas before. I was still happy to have this idea jump to the front of his mind, though:
Finally, I shared the full Riemann sum calculation with him so that he could see how to arrive at the exact answer of 1/3. This part was not as much an exploration for him as it was just me showing him now to do the sum. I was ok with this approach as there is plenty of time after 8th grade to dive into the details of Riemann sums:
I’m very happy that Strogatz shared these unpublished appendixes. They are yet another great way for kids to see some introductory ideas from Calculus.
Yesterday Steven Strogatz shared an unpublished appendix to his book Infinite Powers:
I read it and thought it would be terrific to share with my older son who took calculus last year. This year we’ve been working on Linear Algebra – so not a lot of polynomial calculations (yet!) – so I also thought Strogatz’s appendix would be a terrific review.
I had him read the note first and when he was ready to discuss it we began:
At the end of the last video my son had drawn the picture showing Fermat’s approach to calculating the area under the curve . Now we began calculating. He was able to write down the expression for the approximate area without too much difficulty:
The next step in working through the problem involved some work with a geometric series. Here my son was a little rusty, but I let him spend some time trying to get unstuck:
I just turned the camera off and on at the end of the last video and he continued to struggle with how to manipulate the geometric series into the form we wanted. After a few more minutes of struggle he found the idea, which was really nice to see.
Once he understood the simplification, the rest of Fermat’s proof was easy!
I’m really happy that Strogatz shared his unpublished note yesterday. It is terrific to share with kids who have already had calculus, and would, I think, also be terrific to share with kids studying Riemann sums.
I’m having my older son read a few chapters of Steven Strogatz’s Infinite Powers this summer. We did a calculus course last school year so he has seen some of these calculus concepts before. I’m finding it both fun and fascinating to review some of the ideas with him – there were always lots of ways to review and freshen up the pre-calc ideas, but I still looking for good ways to do that with the ideas from calculus.
Anyway, think of this project as representing with a high school student with a year of calculus under his belt has to say about some of the main ideas from the course.
So, I had him read chapter 6 this morning – here are his initial thoughts:
I asked him to pick two ideas from chapter to talk about. The first idea he wanted to talk about was “instantaneous speed.” Here’s what he took away from the chapter:
The second thing he wanted to talk about was the “Usain Bolt” problem. This part of Strogatz’s book has received a lot of attention – here’s an article in Quanta Magazine, for example:
Quanta Magazine’s article about Infinite Powers
Here’s what my son had to say about the problem:
I’m always really interested to hear kids describe math concepts, but I’m not used to hearing kids talk through Calculus ideas. Hopefully we’ll have some fun over the next few years finding ways to review the main ideas. Probably Infinite Powers will be a great resource!
I got my copy of Steven Strogatz’s new book back in April:
I’ve used it for two projects with my kids already:
Using Steven Strogatz’s Infinite Powers with a 7th grader
Following up on our conversation about Steven Strogatz’s Infinite Powers with some basic calculus ideas
Today my older son was back from camp and I thought it would be fun to try an experiment that is described in the first part of chapter 3 of the book. The experiment involves a ball rolling down a ramp and is based on an experiment of Galileo’s that Strogatz describes.
I started by having my son read the first part of chapter 3 and then tell me what he learned:
Now we took a shot at measuring the time it takes for the ball to roll down the ramp.
I misspoke in this video – we’ll be taking the measurement of the distance the ball travels after 1 second and then after 2 seconds. I’m not sure what made me think we needed to measure it at 4 seconds.
Anyway, here’s the set up and the 5 rolls we used to measure the distance after 1 second.
Here’s the measurement of the distance the ball rolled after 2 seconds. We were expecting the ratio of the distances to be 4 to 1. Unfortunately we found that the ratio was closer to 2 to 1.
We guessed (or maybe hoped!) that the problem in the last two videos was that the ramp wasn’t steep enough. So, we raised the ramp a bit and this time we did find that the distances traveled after two seconds was roughly 4 times the distance traveled after 1 second.
This is definitely a fun experiment to try out with kids. Also a nice lesson that physics experiments can be pretty hard for math people to get right 🙂
My copy of Steven Strogatz’s new book arrived a few weeks ago:
The book is terrific and the math explanations are so accessible that I thought it would be fun to ask my younger son to read the first chapter and get his reactions.
Here’s what he thought and a short list if things that he found interesting:
After that quick introduction we walked through the three things that caught his eye – the first was the proof that the area of a circle is :
Next up was the “riddle of the wall”:
Finally, we talked through a few of the Zeno’s Paradox examples discussed in chapter 1:
I think you can see in the video that Strogatz’s writing is both accessible and interesting to kids. I definitely think that many of the ideas in Infinite Powers will be fun for kids to explore!
Saw a really neat tweet from Steven Strogatz tonight:
I thought it would be fun to share it with the boys and just listen to how the described what they saw.
Here’s what my older (8th grade) son said:
Here’s what my younger son said when he saw the video:
It is fun to see ideas from advanced mathematics through the eyes of kids 🙂